I just finished reading “Being a Teacher Not a Techer” by JL Wagner. He makes a really good point; teaching is more than just using technology. The success of our students does not depend on the use of technology. Some would have you believe that that is the only way our students can learn or will respond “why should they learn how to do that, the calculator will do that for them.”
I have always felt that one of the main goals of every teacher should be to teach students how to think. When technology can augment that, it is something that should be incorporated. Here is an example from my discipline, mathematics: In elementary school students are taught about fractions, but in recent years many teachers just give them the calculator to do those fraction problems. When those students get to Algebra ( a New Jersey state requirement) and have to find common denominators for algebraic denominators, they don’t really understand the process because their calculator did all the work. A true understanding of fractions would make the Algebra work so much easier- the process is the same, it’s just with variables.
Our vocational teachers have experienced trouble with these same students when it comes to using rulers. Those students can’t measure because they don’t understand what the little lines in between mean.
I am not anti-tech, I just believe that a balance must be achieved. Keep the big picture in mind and ask yourself “Is there something else down the road my students will use this process for that cannot be done by _____ (fill in the technology you would use).” If your answer is yes, then make sure you teach that concept so the students understand the process.